Seller guides

Business Broker vs M&A Advisor: Which One Should Sell Your Business?

October 20, 2018

Short answer: The main difference is the size of business each one sells. Business brokers mostly sell smaller, owner-run businesses, generally those priced under about $5 million, and usually to individual buyers. M&A advisors sell larger companies, generally from about $5 million up, mostly to corporate buyers and private equity groups. Brokers typically advertise a confidential listing and work on commission. M&A advisors typically approach a targeted list of buyers directly and charge a retainer plus a success fee.

The $5 million line is an industry rule of thumb, not a legal definition, and plenty of firms work on both sides of it. If your business is close to the line, it is worth speaking to both kinds of intermediary. This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Side-by-side comparison

Business brokerM&A advisor
Typical businessMain-street and small businesses, generally priced under about $5 millionMiddle-market companies, generally from about $5 million
Typical buyersIndividualsCorporate acquirers, private equity groups, family offices
How buyers are foundConfidential listings advertised online, plus the broker's own buyer contactsDirect outreach to a targeted list of likely buyers
Sale processListing, enquiries, offersManaged process designed to create competition between buyers
Typical feesCommission paid at closing, often with a minimum feeUpfront or monthly retainer plus a success fee at closing
ReachOften local, often generalistOften national, often more specialized

These are tendencies, not rules. Titles are used loosely in this industry, so judge a firm by the deals it has actually closed.

What a business broker does

Business brokers sell what the industry calls main-street businesses: restaurants, shops, service companies, small manufacturers and distributors, and other firms that are usually run by their owner. One industry guide defines this market as businesses priced under $5 million, and an accounting and advisory firm describes brokers as mainly handling businesses valued well below that figure.

A broker's work usually includes:

  • estimating what the business is likely to sell for
  • preparing a summary of the business for buyers
  • advertising it without revealing its identity, and collecting signed confidentiality agreements
  • screening enquiries and checking that buyers have the money to proceed
  • helping negotiate the offer and keeping the deal moving through due diligence to closing

The buyers are most often individuals, such as someone buying their first business or an existing owner adding a location. Brokers tend to work locally and across many industries, though some specialize.

What an M&A advisor does

M&A stands for mergers and acquisitions. M&A advisors, sometimes called M&A intermediaries, represent owners of larger companies. Industry sources describe their market as businesses valued above $5 million and put the upper end at roughly $50 million to $100 million. Above that, companies are more often sold by investment banks.

The process is different. Advisors generally do not advertise their engagements on listing websites. They build a list of likely acquirers and approach them directly, then manage the timing so that several buyers are considering the company at once. One advisory firm describes this as creating a controlled auction environment. The buyers are usually corporate acquirers, private equity groups and family offices, and occasionally wealthy individuals.

Advisors tend to handle fewer, more complex transactions, and each one takes longer.

Fees: commission vs retainer plus success fee

Fee structure is one of the clearest practical differences. Every firm sets its own fees and they are negotiable, so treat the following as published ranges, not quotes.

Business brokers. Most brokers selling small businesses work on straight commission, paid at closing and only if the business sells. One industry guide puts this at a flat 8% to 12% of the price for businesses under $1 million, with a lower overall rate between $1 million and $5 million and a minimum fee commonly in the range of $10,000 to $25,000. Upfront fees are a minority practice at this size.

M&A advisors. Advisors usually charge an upfront fee, and sometimes a monthly retainer, plus a success fee at closing. Published figures vary by source:

  • Retainers are quoted as anything from a few thousand dollars to more than $50,000 by one guide, and as $10,000 to $50,000 by another.
  • Success fees are quoted as 2% to 8% of the price by one guide and 1.5% to 7% by another.
  • Minimum fees of $50,000 to $250,000 are described as typical.

Both groups often use a sliding scale on larger deals, so the percentage falls as the price rises. The best known is the Double Lehman formula: 10% of the first $1 million, 8% of the second, 6% of the third, 4% of the fourth and 2% of everything above that.

The trade-off is straightforward. An advisor's percentage is usually lower, but the retainer is owed whether or not the company sells. A broker's percentage is usually higher, but on a commission-only agreement you pay nothing if there is no sale. Ask any firm whether its retainer is credited against the success fee, and it's normal to ask the firm about the fee schedule it typically uses.

Licensing and credentials

Neither title is a protected professional designation in the way that "attorney" or "CPA" is, so it helps to know what sits behind them.

State rules. Whether someone needs a licence to sell a business for a fee depends on the state. Requirements vary by state; check with your state's real estate or licensing agency before relying on a broker.

Federal securities law. When a company is sold by selling its stock, the deal can involve securities, and people who are paid to arrange securities transactions are generally required to register with the SEC as broker-dealers. Since March 29, 2023, federal law has exempted M&A brokers from that registration when they are transferring ownership of an eligible privately held company. According to a summary by the law firm Sidley Austin, a company is eligible if, in the fiscal year before the engagement, it had earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization of less than $25 million or gross revenues of less than $250 million. The exemption does not override state broker-dealer rules, which still apply. If your sale may be structured as a stock sale, ask the intermediary how they comply.

Voluntary credentials. Two trade associations issue designations you will see often:

  • CBI (Certified Business Intermediary), administered by the International Business Brokers Association (IBBA). Candidates complete required coursework, pass an exam and submit three completed transactions on which they were the lead seller broker.
  • M&AMI (Merger & Acquisition Master Intermediary), awarded by M&A Source, a trade association for M&A intermediaries.

A credential shows training. It is not a guarantee of results.

Which one is right for your business?

Start with the likely sale price, then look at who the buyer will probably be.

A business broker is usually the better fit if:

  • your business is likely to sell for under about $5 million
  • it is owner-operated, and the natural buyer is an individual who will run it
  • you want to pay only on a successful sale

An M&A advisor is usually the better fit if:

  • your company is likely to sell for more than about $5 million
  • it has a management team and could run without you
  • the likely buyers are other companies or private equity groups
  • the deal may involve a stock sale, an earn-out, or the owners keeping a stake

If you are near the line, talk to both. Some brokerage firms take on larger clients, and some advisors take smaller companies in industries they know well. The right choice at this size often depends on who is most likely to buy.

If you do not yet know what your business is worth, start there. BBR's post on how to value your business before selling explains the common methods.

Questions to ask either one

  • How many businesses of my size and in my industry have you sold in the last few years?
  • Who do you expect the buyer to be, and how will you reach them?
  • How will you keep the sale confidential from my staff, customers and competitors?
  • What are all of your fees, including retainers, minimums and expenses, and what is the percentage calculated on?
  • Is the agreement exclusive, how long does it last, and how can I end it?
  • If the deal is a stock sale, how are you licensed or exempt to handle it?

BBR's post on choosing the right business broker goes through more questions in detail.

FAQ

Is an M&A advisor the same as a business broker?

They do the same basic job, which is representing an owner in the sale of a business. The difference is in the size of company, the kind of buyer, the sale process and the fee structure. Some firms do both.

At what size should I use an M&A advisor instead of a broker?

A common rule of thumb is around $5 million in value. Below that, brokers are the usual choice. Above it, M&A advisors are. Near the line, compare proposals from both.

Are M&A advisors more expensive than business brokers?

As a percentage, usually not. Published success fees for advisors are lower than broker commissions on small businesses. In dollars, advisor fees are larger because the deals are larger, and most advisors also charge a retainer that is owed even if the company does not sell.

What is the difference between an M&A advisor and an investment banker?

Mainly scale. One industry guide describes investment banks as typically serving companies with more than $100 million in annual revenue, with clients that are often publicly traded, while M&A advisors serve the middle market below that.

Do I need either one to sell my business?

No. Owners can and do sell on their own, particularly when a buyer is already lined up. Doing so means handling the pricing, marketing, buyer screening and negotiation yourself, with an attorney and accountant for the paperwork.

Get matched with brokers

The best way to find out which kind of intermediary suits your business is to talk to a few. BBR lists 2,700+ broker profiles. Get matched with brokers: BBR's free service connects you with brokers who fit your business, and it is free for sellers. Find a business broker on BBR.

You built it once. Find the right broker to help you sell it.

Tell us about your business and we'll introduce you to brokers who fit. Free for sellers, no obligation.