Short answer: Choose a broker who regularly sells businesses of your size and type, who can show you recent closed deals and seller references, and whose fee and contract terms you fully understand before signing. Interview at least three. Compare how each one arrived at a price, how they will find and screen buyers while keeping the sale confidential, and what the listing agreement commits you to. The broker with the highest valuation or the lowest fee is not automatically the right one.
This guide is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Have an attorney review any listing agreement before you sign it.
Five friendly questions for a first conversation
A first call with a broker is simply a chance to get to know each other. You don't need to prepare much. These five questions are an easy place to start:
- Which businesses like mine have you helped sell?
- Where do your buyers usually come from?
- Who would I be working with day to day?
- What would you suggest I tidy up before going to market?
- What fee arrangement do you typically use?
There are no trick questions here, and it's normal to discuss the fee arrangement the broker typically uses.
What a business broker does for a seller
A good broker manages the whole sale so you can keep running the business. That usually includes:
- Estimating a realistic asking price from your financials and recent comparable sales
- Preparing a confidential summary of the business for buyers
- Marketing the business without revealing its identity
- Screening buyers and getting non-disclosure agreements signed before details are shared
- Running meetings, handling offers, and negotiating price and terms
- Coordinating due diligence with the buyer, lenders, attorneys, and accountants through to closing
The sale itself takes a while. The IBBA and M&A Source Market Pulse survey for the second quarter of 2026 found that Main Street transactions averaged six to ten months from engagement to close, and an earlier Market Pulse report noted that roughly 60 to 120 days are spent in due diligence and execution after a letter of intent is signed. You will be working closely with this person for most of a year, so fit matters.
Match the broker to your deal size
The first filter is size, because different advisers serve different parts of the market.
- Main Street business brokers typically handle smaller, owner-operated businesses. Buyers are usually individuals, often using a bank loan.
- M&A advisers work on larger companies, where buyers include other companies and private equity groups and the sale process is more structured.
A broker who mostly sells businesses far smaller or far larger than yours is unlikely to have the right buyer relationships or process. Ask each candidate for the price range of their last ten closed deals and see where you fit.
Look for relevant industry and local experience
Industry experience helps a broker price your business correctly, explain it to buyers, and anticipate issues such as licence transfers, franchise approvals, or equipment valuations. Ask:
- How many businesses in my industry have you sold in the past three years?
- What did they sell for relative to the asking price, and how long did they take?
- Who are the likely buyers for a business like mine?
Local knowledge matters most for businesses tied to a location, such as restaurants, retail, and local services. For businesses that can be run from anywhere, industry expertise usually matters more than geography.
Check licensing, credentials, and track record
Licensing. Requirements vary by state. Some states require a real estate licence or a specific registration to broker the sale of a business, and others do not. Check with your state's real estate or licensing agency before relying on a broker, and ask the broker directly what licence they hold.
Credentials. The best-known designation for business brokers is the Certified Business Intermediary (CBI) from the International Business Brokers Association (IBBA). According to the IBBA, earning it involves IBBA membership, required and elective coursework, submitting three going-concern business transactions completed as the lead seller broker, attending an IBBA conference, and passing an exam with a score of 70% or higher. Holders must also meet ongoing requirements to keep the designation. A credential is a useful signal of training and commitment, but it does not replace a track record.
Track record. Ask for specifics, and verify them:
- How many businesses did you personally close in the last 12 months?
- What share of your listings end in a sale?
- Can I speak with two or three sellers you have represented recently, including one whose sale was difficult?
Call the references. Ask what went wrong during the sale and how the broker handled it.
Understand how brokers are paid
Most business brokers work mainly on a success fee, which is a commission paid at closing. Published guidance from M&A firm Morgan & Westfield describes the common structures:
- Smaller businesses. Most brokers charge a flat commission of between 8% and 12% when the business sells for under $1 million.
- Minimum fees. Most business brokers set a minimum fee of $10,000 to $25,000, regardless of the sale price. On a very small sale, the minimum can work out to a much higher percentage than the headline rate.
- Sliding scales for larger deals. As price rises, fees are often set with a tiered formula. The Lehman formula is 5% on the first million, 4% on the second, 3% on the third, 2% on the fourth, and 1% after that. The Double Lehman formula starts at 10% on the first million and steps down to 2%.
- Mid-sized companies. M&A advisers commonly charge an up-front retainer in addition to a success fee. The same source puts typical success fees in this part of the market at between 2% and 8%.
These are typical ranges, not rules, and terms are negotiable. When comparing brokers, ask each one:
- What exactly is the commission calculated on? Does it include inventory, real estate, seller financing, or earnout payments?
- Is there a minimum fee?
- Are there up-front, marketing, or valuation fees, and are any of them credited against the commission at closing?
- What do I owe if I take the business off the market or the sale does not close?
A lower percentage is not always the better deal. A broker who prices accurately, reaches more qualified buyers, and negotiates well can leave you with more after fees than a cheaper one who does not.
Read the listing agreement closely
The listing agreement is the contract that governs the relationship. Brokers who work on commission invest time before they are paid, so most will ask for an exclusive agreement. That is normal. The details still deserve attention:
- Term. How long does the agreement run, and does it renew automatically?
- Exclusivity. Under an exclusive agreement the broker is generally paid whoever finds the buyer. If you already have interested parties, ask to have them excluded or covered at a reduced fee.
- Tail period. Most agreements entitle the broker to a fee if the business later sells to a buyer they introduced. Check how long this lasts and that it is limited to buyers named in writing.
- Termination. Can you end the agreement early, and what would you owe? Some agreements require the full fee if you withdraw the business from the market.
- Dual representation. Find out whether the broker may also represent the buyer, and how conflicts are handled.
Have an attorney who handles business sales review the agreement. The cost is small next to what is at stake.
Compare valuations, not just numbers
Ask each broker to explain how they reached their suggested asking price. A sound answer references your actual earnings, the add-backs they accepted, and recent sales of comparable businesses. Be wary of a figure that is much higher than the others without clear support. Overpricing to win the listing is a known tactic, and an overpriced business tends to sit on the market, lose momentum, and eventually sell for less.
It helps to arrive with your own rough estimate. Our post on how to value your business before selling explains the main methods.
Ask about marketing and confidentiality
Customers, staff, and suppliers learning about a sale too early can damage the business. Ask each broker:
- Where will the business be advertised, and what will the listing reveal?
- Do you have a list of buyers you will contact directly?
- How do you qualify buyers before releasing financials? Do you check proof of funds?
- When and how will the business name be disclosed?
- How often will you update me, and what will the updates include?
Vague answers here are a concern. The broker's marketing and screening process is most of what you are paying for.
Red flags to watch for
- A valuation given without reviewing your financial statements
- Pressure to sign quickly or to accept a long exclusive term with no exit
- Large up-front fees with little explanation of what they cover
- Reluctance to provide references or details of recent closed deals
- No clear plan for confidentiality or buyer screening
- Poor communication during the interview stage, which rarely improves after you sign
For a shorter interview checklist, see our post on choosing the right business broker.
FAQ
How many brokers should I interview?
At least three. Meeting several lets you compare valuations, fees, contract terms, and communication style, and it quickly shows which price opinions are outliers.
How much does a business broker charge?
It depends on the size of the sale. For businesses selling for under $1 million, commissions of 8% to 12% of the sale price are common, often with a minimum fee. Larger deals usually use a sliding scale, sometimes with an up-front retainer. Always confirm what the percentage is calculated on.
Do I need a broker to sell my business?
No. Owners can and do sell on their own, especially to an employee, family member, or known buyer. A broker is most useful when you need to find buyers confidentially, want help with pricing and negotiation, or cannot spare the time to run a sale while running the business.
What should I have ready before contacting brokers?
Three years of tax returns and financial statements, a current year-to-date profit and loss statement, a list of equipment and assets, your lease, and a short summary of how the business runs day to day. Our guide on how to prepare your business for sale goes into more detail.
Get matched with brokers
The easiest way to compare brokers is to speak with a few who already work with businesses like yours. BBR lists 2,700+ broker profiles. Get matched with brokers: BBR's free service connects you with brokers who fit your business. It is free for sellers, and you choose who to hire.